Thursday, February 13, 2014

Councilwoman calls for class action lawsuit against the city she represents


I’ve seen officials accuse other officials of “working against the city’s best interest” before but it was usually from a mayor trying to stifle a member of the Council for one reason of another.
But, what newly elected Councilwoman Anastasia Robertson, D-District 2, posted on Facebook is beyond any measure of petty political bickering.
She wrote: “Power in CLASS ACTION SUITS.....victims can band together and file in the federal courts.....POWER in CLASS ACTIONS SUITS......”
ROBERTSON
Her post was in response to one started by Rev. Willie Bacote, presumably addressing comments made by Tina Urzan during Wednesday’s Public Safety Committee meeting where the proprietor of Olde Judge Mansion said racism didn’t exist in Troy until Bacote showed up.
Bacote wrote:
Racism did not exist until I got here?
INTERLOPER ?
Tactics of the devil, We The Troy African American Pastoral Alliance are now more United than ever before because you attack one, you attacked Us All!!
Pastor Willie is not the Problem In Troy, NY
I suppose his post could also be in response to Police Benevolent Association President Bob Fitzgerald, who on Wednesday called on Bacote to resign from the alliance.
Either way, urging alleged victims of police brutality to ban together and sue the city she was elected to serve – and swore an oath reflecting as much – is just beyond the grasp of any rational person.
If Robertson, who is black, believes racism exists within the TPD, there are ways to go about trying to fix it without urging the alleged victims to sue the city for what could be millions of dollars.
First, she can help find out what actually happened. Yes, the videos show a disturbing scene where officers enter the establishment when everyone seemed to be leaving in an orderly fashion. Then all hell breaks loose when they attempt to arrest Rashwon Donley. The officer clearly hit Donley with a nightstick while others were restraining him. Police claim Donley hit the officer first and force was justified.
Police also released video of the scene outside the bar and it did look pretty crazy. In the end five people were arrested and eight officers were injured, six needing hospital care. But, while Bacote and others claim police inflamed the situation, police say the situation was already an inferno.

I don’t know. I wasn’t there. I’m not sure if Robertson was there or not.
The only way to find out to the satisfaction of everyone involved is to have an outside entity examine the videos frame by frame and find and talk to some people actually involved in the ruckus.
Until that happens, Robertson would better serve her district and the by doing about anything but advocating for class action lawsuit.
I’m not saying she should just roll with everything that is going on by any stretch. She was duly elected to not be a robot, but to speak her mind and take a stand on things. She is doing that and for that I give her credit. (Though, she did pass on chairing a committee, which is part of being on the Council and all eight of her colleagues accepted that responsibility.)
She would be wiser, however, to march with Bacote, speak against any injustices she sees or has seen, work with Police Chief John Tedesco to implement the structural changes he was talking about Wednesday night or maybe even get to know some of the cops she and others have already indicted for heinous crimes.
Or, since many of the crowd at Kokopellis on Jan. 25 were black and are, for right or wrong, probably leery of police, she could even facilitate bringing the two sides together so the minority voice is heard where it matters rather than through papers filed by attorneys looking for a third of the settlement.   


54 comments:

  1. Excuse me but sharing information with the public is not the same thing as initiating it. Why would it be upsetting for a lawmaker to explain a remedy is available when they are looking for redress? Its precisely the kind of leadership that woul prevent somone trying to seek redress in an unproductive way. Checks and Balances are a part of good government. and are to be encouraged by all. Both the Executive and Legislative branches should enourage any resident to go to the judicial branch because it provides confidence in the entire process.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not when you are elected to the City you are telling people to file the lawsuit against, not to mention she sits on the Public Safety board. Unethical. and she posted similar things in the Enough!!!End Police Violence!!! event on Facebook. Sorry, she sold all of us out and there is NOT any Justice for US in Troy when an elected official pulls a stunt like this.

      Delete
    2. Yo stay in Albany and serve the disenfranchised over there. The people here can't afford to pay the taxes as it is. One question seeing as you are an expert on everything, what do you call it when a group of people are punished or ridiculed for the actions of a few? That's the problem with "you people" everybody wants to lead the flock, I would like you to get the flock out of here.

      Delete
  2. Troy Democrats could get a corpse elected. The people of Troy deserve thius type of government, and taxpayers deserve to pay the price of lawsuits from their elected officials. You get wHT YOU DESEERVE, SPECIAL INTEREST COMMUNIST DEMOTGRATES1

    ReplyDelete
  3. As a resident of Troy I am pissed! Not only has she sold out her constituents from D2 she has sold out all of the taxpayers and the people who live in the City of Troy. WORST of ALL she just sold out the entire Troy Police Dept. As a councilperson and member of the Public Safety Committee this is blatantly disrespectful to all of us and positively biased towards one group, which is UNACCEPTABLE as an elected official.. Therefore needs to recuse herself from the Public Safety Committee.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. PS Committee? How about stepping right off the council? She should be removed from office. 2 months in, and she & Munster have already violated their oath of office with their sheer stupidity.

      Delete
  4. New
    Majority is phony activist community


    Major new is better thank old mAjor? Not tuere becauas Major Harris is real leaser not bloke new major

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 11:57 ---Were you one of those kids who kept skipping school? I find your comment, very confusing. In English next time please.

      Delete
    2. Hey, don't harass the guy because he's mentally challenged. Most of harry's voters were or they were on drugs.

      Delete
  5. Another day, another ethics investigation of a Troy Democrat. When will it end.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Voting Row A is getting painful, and expensive.

      Delete
    2. Row B costs too much in lawsuits and padded retirements.

      Delete
  6. Everyone who has talked on this issue has done a bad job - black or white, police or public, mayor or council - all have botched this. The other 49,800 of us are now telling you to shut-up and work together to better the city. There should be no sides when it comes to what's best for all of us.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Tell me you don't miss Mark McGrath.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Loved his furry sweater

      Delete
    2. He has always been there for the pickannys all threw his district for 8 years

      Delete
    3. Another HRT ---it's THROUGH ---not threw. Burgh grad are you?

      Delete
  8. If I had a law degree I would setup shop in Troy. Everyday another lawsuit, and we the taxpayers suffer.I would like to know if anyone on the council talks to each other? Perhaps if they shared these stupid ideas first they might not act on them? You work for the people, all the people of Troy. I want my city in the news for good works.Work together ! Law suits should be a last resort.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. half the problem is the GOP keeps running folks like you!

      Delete
  9. Tom Wade is doing a wonderful job for the City of Troy with the democrats he runs for office! Keep up the good work Tom.

    ReplyDelete
  10. How F@&king great is this!!!! Earlier in the week Vito was summonsed to city hall to be scolded for calling Bob Doherty a dope on Facebook. This had the Two Tone Tung Whitshire very upset and he called Mayor Lou looking for Vito's head on a silver plater. Can't wait for Lou to call her in TODAY for this Facebook undermining of the Troy tax payers. Oh and by the way Lou Doherty is a dope.

    ReplyDelete
  11. As a person with no skin in the game (except as a white living in north central at the eve of a race war) The person who has spoke and done what seems to be the most correct thing has been Tedesco.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Troy is a joke because YOU continue to elect half retarded democrats

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am very offended by this statement. Singed half a retard

      Delete
    2. It's SIGNED!!!!!!!! That little red line that appears as you're typing means you SPELLED IT WRONG. Damn Troy school system.

      Delete
    3. Again... Please be wary of insulting an entire school system.

      Delete
  13. No leadership and no control. Harry Tutunjian w have been in charge of this situation. The Nice Bous have no ability but to make people feel happy and pleasure.

    ReplyDelete
  14. NOT TO MENTION copwatch 518 facebook page. Whoever runs that, has a picture of Tina on it as she spoke at the last meeting. Stating "this is what a racist looks like". I would sue them!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Tina's speech was clearly racist.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There where plenty of racist speeches to go around

      Delete
    2. Did you hear hightops rant up at 41 bar and grill

      Delete
    3. The other side is racist too, except its against white people. Ya'll can thank Willie for that. He's a racist hypocrite!

      Delete
  16. I think that one of the greatest problems faced by our under served/minority groups goes way beyond racial issues. In so many instances, this being one of them, the so-called leadership that people look to for support and inspiration are unfortunately nabobs and miscreants out to further their own agenda by fanning flames. This woman, Anastasia, and the alleged Reverand, Willie Bacote, thrive because the populations they serve do not have any truly credible representatives to work on their behalf - and they don't hold these people accountable for their actions... it is an unfortunate situation and I hope someone with some true substance within this community steps up to make a difference.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There is that one person who can step up and make this a better situation .........................DAD. Not baby daddy. Just DAD.

      Delete
  17. One can only imagine the money these 2 idiot council people are going to cost us. Bet there's some attorney's out there just chomping on the bit over these remarks. Cha Ching. Tina's a racist. A racist doesn't open up a business in a primarily black community. She's a good woman who has done plenty for North Central. The immature assholes yelling at her the other night should be ashamed of themselves. She's a business woman who has put her money where her mouth is --unlike many at the meeting.

    ReplyDelete
  18. This is straight from the city charter

    Representation. An officer or employee of the City of Troy shall not represent any other person in any matter that person has before the City nor represent any other person in any matter against the interests of the City.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There is no question then, all 3 should be removed from office.

      Delete
    2. The single person ruining this city is vandenburgh and chamberlain. Rat citizen Vito and sarris and vandenburgh from d school Bruno Mirch crawley keep my nephew from million dollar business

      Delete
    3. Bob it's 2pm...time to take your pills.

      Delete
    4. Vandenberg: Define interests of the city? Eliminating racism in the police department and telling the SLA to hold off on any determination because there is an ongoing investigation to determine the truth would seem to be in the best interest of everyone, including the city administration. It seems to be that you want define "the best interest of the city" as continuing to ignore problems and hide the truth.

      Delete
    5. https://www.change.org/petitions/troy-city-council-and-mayor-lou-rosamillia-immediate-recall-of-city-council-members-rodney-wiltshire-jr-anastasia-robertson-and-robert-j-doherty

      Delete
  19. You have this, Doherty showing up at the SLA and Rodney showing up at ZBA meetings to speak against Solar panels... the city REFUSES to recognize this.

    ReplyDelete
  20. They have not reprimanded Robertson, Doherty or Whilshire but the Mayor made sure he sat Vito down and schit all over him for having an opinion.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Vito was denied his first amendment rights. Come on Lou your smarter than this and he's citizen of the year. Dougherty is just clueless an whats up with the way he talks. Perhaps fiitzy should have breathalyzer him after the meeting on the way home in the Prius

      Delete
    2. Jay,
      Should you be questioning ethics when you have a Troy Housing job after your chairmanship, which is in clear violation of federal law?

      Delete
    3. yes I am......your another brave soul to put up anonymous post that you are a genius and know all.

      Delete
    4. Yes ok just like as chair you hired your best friend as executive director of the tha. He had no chance against the current administration

      Delete
  21. One party system is not working. Even the democrat voters have to admit it. We need a better mix. This thing is broken.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We do need a better mix, but if people are so stubborn and gullible to believe the BS that's fed to them it's their own fault. Ignoring the problems won't make them go away.

      Delete
    2. your so sure its wrong then call somebody instead of pussy comments on facebook

      Delete
  22. https://www.change.org/petitions/troy-city-council-and-mayor-lou-rosamillia-immediate-recall-of-city-council-members-rodney-wiltshire-jr-anastasia-robertson-and-robert-j-doherty

    Petition to recall Doherty, Robertson and Wiltshire.

    ReplyDelete
  23. This comment by the council woman is highly irresponsible, she should resign. We should be supporting our government and our great police department, keeping the streets safe.

    ReplyDelete